Lore

"We Are Not Our Customers" Heuristic

Overview

A check against decision-makers projecting their own atypical preferences (tech-savvy, terminally online) onto a broader, less tech-adept customer base. When a feature is popular with an internal or expert audience, that popularity is explicitly interrogated for representativeness before it justifies building the feature.

Case: Netflix Party (2021)

"Watch together" social-viewing was pitched with real internal enthusiasm, but the same idea had already failed three times at Netflix over roughly a decade — Netflix Friends (2009, capped ~5% after growing from 2%), Xbox party mode (~2010, capped ~5%), and an international sharing feature (1-2%) — and Disney+ and Hulu independently reported similar ~2% ceilings on their own versions. Despite renewed internal appetite, Netflix chose not to build it.

Related

Complements DHM Model (Delight, Hard-to-Copy, Margin-Enhancing) (a delightful-seeming feature can still fail the hard-to-copy/margin test if its real reach is tiny) and Narrow Audience / Small Group Product Focus (the inverse case — deliberately building for a real minority rather than mistaking it for the majority).