Lore

"Operate Without a PM" Baseline Test

Overview

Peter Sellis's bar for justifying a product manager role: could the product function without one? A PM must demonstrably add value over having nobody in the seat, not merely over an average or bad PM. He grounds this in his broader claim that the PM profession is structurally mediocre (see pm-quality-power-law), noting that great engineers rarely complain about product management because they either bend good PMs to their will or simply don't tolerate bad ones.

"I really don't hear great engineers complain about product managers that much because great engineers a) they know how to bend product managers to their will... and b) they just like don't put up with bad ones."

Apply

Before staffing or retaining a PM on a team, ask concretely what would break if the role were removed entirely; if the answer is "nothing," the role isn't earning its seat.

Related