Lore

ecommerce

How Jolie's Co-Founder Built $50M Betting Against Meta

Ryan Babenzien argues that Meta-driven, ROAS-chasing e-commerce is a trap with no remaining edge, and that brand is the last real moat. He says it is built slowly through word of mouth, real-world activations and margin discipline, and that profit matters more than revenue.

Elevator Goods · 2026-06-06 · English

Key ideas

  1. The host frames the premise: most e-commerce pours money into Meta and chases ROAS. Babenzien built Jolie into a nine-figure brand that was profitable from day one, barely used Meta and never discounted.

  2. Babenzien says access is the biggest change in e-commerce. Off-the-shelf tools (Shopify, versus the Magento advice of 2013) make launching cheap and fast. He argues that a website, sourcing and a product are therefore not a brand, and that brand equity is the moat that produces outsized demand without heavy marketing.

  3. He says Meta no longer offers an edge. Media-buying skill used to win, but the algorithm now gives decent outcomes by default and everyone has the same toolbox. Creative has only a slight advantage, so customers must do the heavy lifting through genuine word of mouth.

  4. Jolie's brand thesis was discovered rather than planned. Post-purchase surveys showed customers could not name the dominant $10B shower company, which told them the category lacked brands. Babenzien says customers who become advocates give a competitive advantage that rivals without fan loyalty lack.

  5. He says the market overinvests in paid marketing and that he is 'an outcast' on this among peers. He argues that young founders competing on the lowest break-even ROAS pay a perpetual toll to Meta. Revenue grows while profit shrinks, which leaves unattractive, glorified drop-ship businesses whose successes are anomalies.

  6. Babenzien argues Meta is the only channel with no economies of scale. Costs rise with spend and year over year, and a brand eventually cannot unwind because revenue would halve overnight. He also doubts Meta's reach metrics, since passing eyes without attention is worthless.

  7. He says D2C is a distribution channel rather than a business model. Valuation and hype (Allbirds going from billions to a $39M sale) show that revenue growth without sound unit economics does not save a brand.

  8. Babenzien says he would repeat the Jolie playbook today but that it takes longer. Jolie's speed ($50M in year 4, profitable 15 of 17 quarters) should not be the target. The choice is a fast, thin-margin revenue machine or a slower, sustainable brand, and he calls the brand route 'the only one left'.

  9. He argues that retention is Jolie's real leverage. He claims the lowest churn in beauty, and says the company has not fully mastered it. He also says the beauty industry overlooked water as the biggest source of skin and hair issues, that everyone will eventually use a filtering shower, and that competition (such as Brita's investment in a rival) validates the market.

  10. He contrasts 'digital' with the 'analog world'. Digital is 'a function of capital', whereas events, trucks and culture take planning and time. Babenzien says this is how brands were built before the internet. The payoff shows up as emotion and unprompted comments, which he does not measure in ROAS.

  11. The host and guest agree that experienced operators invest where the return is not instant, while newer founders optimize for clipping a thin margin and collecting Amex points. They tie this to patience and to going against the easy Meta current. The host counts only three e-com moats in 2026.

  12. Babenzien argues that profit beats revenue and that founders should settle their goals before launch. A $20M business at 20% EBITDA beats a $50M business at 5%. VC re-raising is fading, M&A buyers want ever-higher minimum revenue, and volatility (tariffs, oil, politics) is under-discussed, so he recommends a worst-case model and says 'profit equals peace of mind'.

  13. In the rapid-fire close, Babenzien favors Uniqlo, New York and Slack with AI automation. He calls 100-hour weeks overrated and staying physically and mentally dialed in underrated. He names work flexibility as the best perk, and a goal of 20% EBITDA at $50M+ revenue.

  14. Brand as the moat — Babenzien's thesis that brand equity, not site, sourcing or ad skill, is what produces outsized consumer demand without heavy marketing. Apply: Invest in awareness and momentum from sources that are not ad-driven or engineered, and treat a product with only a logo as a weak position.

  15. Customer-advocacy word of mouth — A growth approach where customers do the selling through real-world conversation and posts such as 'I just got Jolie, here are my results after 2 weeks', rather than 'click this link' referral programs. Apply: Put product in many hands without a script, and treat customers who become advocates as the source of competitive advantage.

  16. Post-purchase brand-awareness survey — Jolie's survey asking 'What did you replace your Jolie with?' to learn whether customers recognized incumbent brands. Apply: Run it for the first couple of years and read the answers as a signal of whether the category lacks recognized brands.

  17. Marketing-mix diversification away from Meta — Capping the share of marketing spent on Meta (about 25% at Jolie, with a 5% target) and spreading the rest across other channels. Apply: Reduce Meta's share over time and treat channel choice as agnostic, spending more where it works better.

  18. Analog, in-real-life activations — Non-digital brand building through events and physical presence, such as the pre-launch oyster-and-wine event, 25 trucks in Manhattan, a Hamptons yoga series and a Copenhagen event. Apply: Plan events and physical activations around art, music, fashion, design and food, and judge them by qualitative signals like comments and emotion rather than ROAS.

  19. Curated culture-shaping community — A community of real New York people in art, fashion and design, not online creators, who influence others without large followings. Apply: Seed the product with these people before and after launch and let their influence spread the brand.

  20. Be greedy with margin — Babenzien's rule that margin can only be defined once, before launch, so a product should be priced for a premium with a justified reason. Apply: Do not compete on price against the dominant player. Target a smaller, higher-margin market, like the $12 AirPod cover with a reason it is worth it versus the $5 generic.

  21. Add retail to e-commerce for blended CAC — Pairing direct sales with retail partners such as Ulta to balance distribution, margin and CAC profiles. Apply: Once an e-commerce business finds scale, add retail so that blended CAC falls.

  22. Choose your own North Star — Getting product into users' hands as cheaply and quickly as possible while choosing the metric you optimize, which for Babenzien was first-person first-purchase profit. Apply: Pick a profit-based North Star even though it means slower growth.

  23. Host's product-selection framework — The host's criteria for picking a product: size and weight, shipping cost, ability to ship globally, lifetime value and ideally a subscription element, with the brand built after the product and category. Apply: Screen candidate products against these criteria and go after the biggest TAM, favoring habitual behaviors such as sleeping and showering.

  24. Three moats of e-com in 2026 — The host's framing that only three moats remain: brand, supply chain excellence (supplier relationships, cash flow management with the supplier, product quality), and team. Apply: Invest in the three moats, including in ways without instant-gratification ROI.

  25. Profit over revenue (EBITDA comparison) — Babenzien's heuristic that a $20M business at 20% EBITDA beats a $50M business at 5% EBITDA. Apply: Judge growth by profit and cash kept in the bank rather than top-line revenue.

  26. Profit ladder to 20% EBITDA — A staged goal: invest and build brand up to about $50M in revenue, then focus on profit improvement, passing 10% EBITDA and heading toward 20%. Apply: Accept delayed returns up to $50M (which may take 2, 5 or 7 years), then work on the profit profile to gain clarity and long-term thinking.

  27. Pre-launch founder-intent questions — Deciding before launch whether to sell, pay a 5% annual coupon while building, or build over 5, 10 or 20 years, framed with a marriage analogy. Apply: Hold this conversation with your business partner and ask what you want at 40, 50, 60 and 70, so you avoid an unintended hamster wheel.

  28. Worst-case scenario model — A planning response to volatility from tariffs, oil prices and politics that cannot be forecast. Apply: Keep a worst-case model so growth does not become a liability through cash outflow and held inventory.

  29. Slack plus AI/MCP automated reporting — Babenzien's tool setup of Slack with AI tools piping in via MCPs to automate reporting. Apply: Automate report pulls and similar tasks to improve efficiency and time management.

  30. Natural CAC / lowest break-even ROAS (counter-example) — The strategy Babenzien criticizes: accept CAC and fix it through price increases, upsells and bundles, competing on the lowest break-even ROAS (such as profit at 1.5). Apply: Recognize it as 'paying the piper' to Meta, where revenue grows and profit shrinks, and avoid it.

Insights

Babenzien says Jolie's post-purchase question 'What did you replace your Jolie with?' showed that customers did not know the $10B incumbent. He treated the survey as evidence that brand-building in the category was open.

He says Meta is the one channel where more spend makes things worse. A brand reaches a point where it cannot cut Meta spend without revenue halving overnight, and the host says the glide-down can take about two years.

He says 'natural CAC' (accept CAC and fix it with price increases, upsells and bundles) is a Meta derivative that grows revenue while profit shrinks. He adds that a revenue machine with thin profit is unattractive to acquirers.

He says Jolie spends about 25% of marketing on Meta, wants it at 5%, and says the brand will get there over time.

Babenzien says the margin decision is made only once, before launch. His example is a $5 silicone AirPod cover versus a $12 one with a justified reason, in a smaller, higher-margin market, which he calls 'the great equalizer'.

He says a scaling e-commerce brand should add retail early. Retail partners like Ulta have a different acquisition cost, so blended CAC falls and distribution and margin profiles balance out.

The oyster-and-wine pre-launch event had a rationale: oysters naturally filter water, and one oyster can filter 50 gallons a day. Babenzien says the community is curated and culture-shaping, made of real people in New York art, fashion and design rather than online creators with large followings.

He does not measure the ROI of the 25 Manhattan trucks in ROAS. He cites daily comments and emotion that digital ads do not get. Jolie also runs events where it does not sell, such as a Copenhagen event and a Hamptons yoga series every summer since the start.

He cites the sneaker secondary market as an analog precedent. People flew to Japan for colors unavailable in America, shipped them back and sold them for 10x, which he calls a laborious analog way of making a living that worked.

Babenzien says the M&A market's minimum-revenue threshold has risen in beauty and in every industry. This creates a misalignment with founders who bootstrap for profit and who, without clear intent, end up 'on this hamster wheel that you didn't realize you were on'.

He notes that tariffs were ruled illegal and the tariff money is to be refunded, which he says could create a surprise cash bonus later. He uses this to illustrate volatility that cannot be planned for.

He says the defining question is what the founder wants out of the company: a sale, a 5% annual coupon while building, or a 5-, 10- or 20-year build. He likens this to marriage and says very few founders and partners ever have that conversation.

«Profit equals peace of mind. Period.»

— 48:47

«if you don't invest in this machine of yourself, you won't get the best outcome.»

— 46:51

«D2C is not a business model. D2C is a distribution channel.»

— 29:17

«It's the only channel I've ever seen where the more you spend the worse it gets.»

— 30:36

«Be greedy with margin. You have one moment in time where you can actually define your own margin. It's before you launch.»

— 26:09

«Revenue means nothing. At the end of the day, you don't get that money.»

— 38:40

«13 years for it to go from zero to zero.»

— 22:24

«I do think the playbook is the only one left, frankly.»

— 15:05

«I am an outcast in my peer set about how my opinion on Meta.»

— 10:53

Reception

Mostly warm and enthusiastic, with viewers praising the guest and the content as brilliant and validating, tempered by a skeptical top comment about fundraising enabling the no-ROAS stance, a request for more detail on the marketing mix, and some spam and self-promotion.

This is a coherent, experience-backed contrarian case for slow, profit-first brand building over paid-acquisition growth. It is stronger on principles and anecdotes (trucks, events, margin discipline) than on specifics such as the other 75% of Jolie's marketing mix.

49:12

↳ Elevator Goods · YouTube

Watch original