A companion practice to Phil Jackson–Style Talent-Meshing Leadership: judge an unconventional high performer by their body of work over time — like an artist's discography — rather than condemning them for any single weak project. This protects retention of "spiky" top talent who may have an off cycle without erasing an otherwise-strong track record.
When a strong-but-unconventional PM ships a weak project, review their track record over time before deciding whether to keep backing them.